These gluten-free thumbprint cookies are also grain-free and dairy-free! They have a fantastic texture and can be adapted to use different zests, extracts and jams.
I love gluten-free cookies like these year-round. I don’t understand why raspberry thumbprints are a Christmas thing. I mean, they’re raspberry flavored!
To me, that screams summer. So here’s a little piece of summer for you in December.
Use whatever flavors you’d like
I first made these cookies in January when I was experiencing the post-Christmas winter blues. So of course I loaded them with lemon zest and extract. Lemon does a great job of cheering me up.
With Christmas around the corner, I thought I ought to try an almond version and they were just as delicious.
Or maybe even more delicious?! It’s hard to pick a favorite.
You can of course use whatever extract and jam you’d like. Some commenters have used apricot jam and I think that sounds amazing in combination with almond extract. Blueberry jam would also be great!
A less fussy dough
The dough in these raspberry thumbprint cookies is almost the same as the one in my lemon curd thumbprints. Except I made these dairy-free!
To do that, I just used coconut oil instead of butter and reduced the amount by a tablespoon. The two types of fat are often not interchangeable in cookie recipes.
And the raspberry version is actually a little less fussy! For whatever reason, you have to pre-bake the lemon curd cookies a little before adding the curd.
They came out looking funky when I made the indentation, added the lemon curd and then baked.
These raspberry thumbprints get rid of that pre-baking step. It’s not much but I’ll take one less step as an improvement!
How to decorate thumbprint cookies
I think a powdered sugar glaze is pretty standard with thumbprint cookies but I know most of my regular readers don’t like it when I use powdered sugar (neither do I) so I just used some melted white chocolate. It’s also full of white sugar so it’s not really any better, but at least it tastes like something other than pure sugar.
I think these gluten-free thumbprint cookies are quite pretty without the white chocolate on top so you can easily leave it out. That means less washing up, which is always good. ;) If you want to use white chocolate and need these cookies to be dairy-free, you can make your own dairy-free white chocolate.
Using different types of sugar?
I used a light-colored raw sugar in the cookie dough and recommend thinking twice before using a dark raw sugar or coconut sugar. You don’t want the molasses-y taste to interfere with the light almond taste!
If you need something that’s free of refined sugar, check out my paleo peppermint cookies, gluten-free orange cookies or peanut butter cookies.
These gluten-free molasses cookies are also amazing! They remind me of the Archway cookies from my childhood.
If you try out these gluten-free thumbprints, please let me know how you like them!
Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies (grain-free, gluten-free, dairy-free)
- Prep Time:
- Cook Time:
- Ready in:
- Yield: 32 cookies
Ingredients
- 2 cups (200 grams) blanched almond flour (called ground almonds in other countries)
- 1/4 cup (34 grams) coconut flour, sifted if lumpy
- 1/2 cup (100 grams) raw or granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon baking powder
- 1/8 teaspoon salt
- 7 tablespoons (98 grams) coconut oil 1 or 1/2 cup (113 grams) butter if you can have dairy, melted and cooled slightly
- 1 large egg, room temperature
- 1 teaspoon almond extract
- 1/3 cup (100 grams) raspberry jam or jam of choice
- 1/2 cup (85 grams) white chocolate for piping, optional (omit for dairy-free)
Directions
- In a medium bowl, stir together the almond flour, coconut flour, sugar, baking powder and salt.
- In another medium bowl, stir together the coconut oil, egg and almond extract.
- Add the flour mixture to the wet mixture and stir just until combined. The dough will feel quite wet. Let sit for 10 minutes, which allows the coconut flour to absorb the liquid.
- Preheat the oven to 350 °F (175 °C) and line a cookie sheet with a piece of parchment paper.
- Roll the dough into 1" balls and place 2" apart on the prepared cookie sheet. The dough will feel quite greasy but this is okay.
- Using your thumb, make an indentation about 3/4 of the way down into each cookie. You may want to re-form the edges a little to make them prettier.
- Fill each indentation with 1/2 teaspoon of jam. Be sure not to overfill them.
- Bake for 8 minutes or until the cookies have barely started browning on the bottom.
- Let the cookies, which will be very soft, cool for 5 minutes on the baking sheet and then remove to a wire rack to cool completely.
- Pipe with white chocolate, if desired.
- Store in an airtight container for up to 4 days.
Notes
- If you use unrefined coconut oil, these will likely have a coconut taste to them. With refined coconut oil, there will be no coconut taste.
Adapted from my lemon curd thumbprint cookies
Join over 12,400 readers and sweeten up
your inbox with new posts for free!
This subscription is free of charge and can be canceled at any time.
254 comments on “Gluten-free Thumbprint Cookies (grain-free, dairy-free)” — Add one!
18 comments are awaiting moderation!
What can I use in place of the coconut flour?
I’m so sorry for just now seeing your question! There’s unfortunately not a sub for coconut flour as it’s so more absorbent than all other types of flour. Sorry about that. I so wish there were!
Do these work out if you coat the outside in chopped almonds?
I haven’t tried it, but I think it’d work! You might need an egg white or something to get the almonds to stick.
Followed the recipe exactly and turned out perfectly – amazing taste. Definitely a winner recipe to use again so thank you!
I’m so glad that you enjoyed the cookies and that you’ll be making them again! Thanks a bunch for your comment. :)
My daughter especially likes the thumbprint cookies, says they remind her of eating marzipan. I make them for our grandson who is gluten and dairy free. Altogether a winner.Thanks for the great recipe. Will be trying others
You’re welcome! I’m really glad that you enjoyed them so much. Thanks a ton for your feedback! I hope you’ll enjoy the other recipes just as much. :)
I love this recipe. It is one of my favorite Christmas cookies. They are easy to put together and tastes great.
Yay! I’m so glad to hear that! And I’m sorry for just now seeing your comment. It got lost somehow. :/
Could you use an egg substitute to make these vegan?
I haven’t tried it, unfortunately, so I can’t say for sure. It only calls for 1 egg, though, so I’m optimistic it’d work. Just can’t be positive!
I made these this weekend. They are amazing! Can’t even tell they are gluten/dairy free. Thank you!
You’re welcome! I’m so happy that you liked them so much. :) I’m sorry for just now seeing your comment. It got stuck in spam for some reason.
Can these be frozen?
Yes!
Hi can I use rice flour or a different flour? Almond flour is way too expensive where I live and I cannot have coconut flour any alternatives your recommend? Thank you!
Unfortunately not. If you can’t use the flours in this recipe, you’d need to find a recipe that uses the flours you can use. :/ Sorry about that!
Would dairy free butter work in place of the coconut oil? We’re very very new to the dairy and gluten free world.
I haven’t tried it but it should work without an issue in place of the amount of butter given. :)
I used butter instead and it worked great!
Awesome! I’m glad to hear that. :)
I am so excited to try these thumbprint cookies!! They are amazing!
These are fantastic! The perfect little treat!
Cookies came out great! But just wondering, why do they need to be refrigerated? I dusted them with powder sugar (they look so pretty), instead of piping them with frosting & I don’t want the powder sugar to disappear, as it probably would in the fridge. Please advise. . .
Sorry for just now seeing this! You’re right. They don’t need to be refrigerated. Will change that in the recipe! I’m glad you enjoyed them. :)
Hi! Planning on making these but I don’t have coconut flour on hand, is there another substitute I can use instead or does it have to be used? Thanks so much!!
Hello! There’s unfortunately no sub for coconut flour as it’s so much more absorbent than any other flour. Sorry about that. :/
If I use butter instead of coconut oil do I need to melt the butter or just soften it?
You should melt it and slightly cool it :)
I’ve been gluten free for 9 years. Rarely do I bake a gf recipe that I really like. These cookies… LOVE! The texture is amazing, the hint of almond is perfection! This recipe is a keeper!
Woohoo! I’m so glad to hear that. :) But super sad that you rarely bake something gluten-free that you like. Please check out my sweets for other recipes. :) Thanks a ton for your feedback!
Ours didn’t bind well. There was not enough moisture and I can’t figure out what we did wrong
Did you make any changes at all to the recipe (slightly different ingredients, a different sized egg, changing the order of mixing, etc.)? What brand of almond flour did you use?
Can canola oil be used
I haven’t tried it but I wouldn’t recommend it. I’d suggest sticking to something solid – so either coconut oil or butter.
Can these be frozen to enjoy later?
Yes, they can. :)
Hi! My sister in law is GF and dairy free. My father in law is diabetic and on a low-carb, sugar free diet. I am trying to make this recipe work for both by using Swerve (sugar substitute). Is this recipe considered keto, or low carb, friendly?
Hello! If you replaced the sugar and used sugar-free jam, then it would be keto. :) I have no idea if Swerve would work here, though. My stomach doesn’t like it so I don’t have much experience with it. Sorry I can’t be more helpful!
If I am subbing butter for coconut oil, how much should I use? Will it still be the 7 tbsp? Thanks!
I’m sorry for just now seeing your question! Hopefully you found the answer in the post. :) Use 8 tablespoons of butter.
Saw the comment on using honey in place of raw or granulated sugar – do the same comments apply? Was going to try it since my stepdaughter is sugar free as well as all the rest…..Thanks. I want to surprise her with these since I have made these with butter, sugar and wheat flour for years and are a family favorite. She thought she would never be able to have these types of cookies again. Hoping this great recipe will do the trick!
I’m so sorry for just now seeing your question! Things have been chaotic over here. I’m not sure what you mean with “do the same comments apply.” I searched the post for honey and found one person asking if they can use it and I wrote, “The problem is that there’s no liquid to reduce in the recipe, which is necessary because of the liquid you’re adding from the honey. So I can’t really recommend it. Sorry about that!” I’ve been working on a vegan version of this recipe for a while. It uses maple syrup. I hope to get it done soon because I also don’t like that these use granulated sugar! I hope you can find another recipe for your stepdaughter in the meantime. :)
Can you please let me know how much lemon zest and extract did you add when you initially made these? I’d love to try it since raspberry and lemon is one of my favorite flavor combos! Thanks!
Hi! I have a lemon version here – lemon curd thumbprint cookies. :)
Wow! These are so good! I made with vanilla instead of almond extract and added chopped pecans to the dough. Strawberry preserves is what I had, so I drizzled with bittersweet dairy free chocolate. Amazing! Thank you for a wonderful recipe!
Wow, that sounds delicious! What yummy changes you made. Thanks a bunch for the tip! I’m glad you enjoyed them.
I made these this past weekend and they are delicious and pretty! I am experimenting and trying to find good recipes that I can make for my gluten-sensitive MIL. Even hubby liked them, and he usually turns up his nose at gluten-free anything. Reforming the edges after you press an indentation for the jam is a little challenging, but doable. Patience is the key here. I like Shannon’s idea above about chilling the dough before shaping them – I will try that next time. I used almond bark for the drizzle this time, but I think the white chocolate would add a better taste dimension – I will try that next time as well.
Great recipe! Thanks so much for sharing this!
You’re welcome! I’m so glad that you and your husband liked the cookies. Hopefully your MIL will, too. :) Thanks for your feedback!
Could you use peppermint extract instead of almond? Also thinking about using mint apple jelly instead of raspberry preserves. Your thoughts?
I’m so sorry for just now seeing your question! Peppermint extract sounds great. It might go well with your jelly if it’s also peppermint. Sometimes mint-flavored things are really spearmint but spearmint apple jelly sounds really odd. Sorry again for my slow reply!
So I made one batch with almond flavoring and raspberry jam and another with peppermint extract and mint apple jelly. Both were yummy and pretty for a bridal shower. Thank you for the recipe.
Can you use coconut sugar in these instead of raw or granulated?
I’m so sorry for just now seeing your question! You can but they’ll be darker and also have a darker taste.
What brand of Blanched Almond Flour do you use? Do I get super fine? Or is all Blanched Almond Flour super fine? Either way I need the exact kind you use lol.
Hi! :) I used Bob’s Red Mill Super-fine Almond Flour. All almond flour is not super fine so I recommend that one. Hope you’ll enjoy the cookies! :)
Thank you so much!!!! I will be baking 9 dozen for a cookie exchange on Saturday! These look delicious! I will leave a review to share how everybody likes them! Happy Holidays! Thanks for the recipe! :-)
You’re welcome for the recipe! I hope that everyone enjoyed them! :)
Do you have a recommendation for an egg replacement for these? I typically use flax egg but I was curious if you have a different recommendation.
One of the commenters used aquafaba but I haven’t tried it. I’ve never tried an egg replacement in these so I’m really not sure. They might be a bit more difficult to shape! Sorry I don’t have a better answer for you. :(
I just made them using Bob’s Red Mill Egg Replacer…and they turned out great! I also used ghee instead of coconut oil and arrowroot flour instead of the coconut flour. The texture was superb; nice and soft and chewy…and they held their shape beautifully…and,of course the taste is a winner! 😊
I’m so glad that your subs worked out well! I’m surprised that arrowroot worked in place of coconut flour. Thanks so much for the tips! I love that egg replacer and will try that as well. :)
My family could not stop eating these cookies, they only lasted one day!! I made them without the chocolate since I am not able to eat chocolate. My dad could not believe they were gluten and dairy free. Great recipe – thank you for sharing.
You’re welcome! I’m so glad that you all, especially your dad, enjoyed them so much. :D Thanks a bunch for your comment!
I have tried some of your wonderful recipes and they al delicious! Your selection and library are wonderful! Well done and thank you for all the inspiration! You are a shining star in what yu do!
Aww, thank you! What a nice thing to say. :) I’m really glad you like the recipes! And I’m so sorry for just now seeing your comment! It somehow got mixed in with the spam.
Hubby and I loved these! The Second time making them I used coconut palm sugar instead of Raw sugar. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I’m so glad that you both liked them! Thanks for your comment. :)
This recipe is amazing!! Some of the best gluten free cookies i have ever had! Seriously delicious and i have gotten great complements for my baking skills solely from this awesome recipe.
Wow, I’m so glad to hear that! That’s great that people liked them so much. Thanks for your comment!
Same here! Girls at work want to pay me to make more for them and their husbands!!! They are really delicious!
Yay! I’m so happy to hear that. That’s awesome! Thanks for your comment and sorry for just now seeing it!
Hi, these look yummy.I’m hoping to make them soon. What would be a good sub for the eggs and how much to use? Thanks.
Hi there! I’ve never used an egg sub in these so I’m not positive it’d work. I’m guessing 1 chia or flax egg would work (but it’s really just a guess!).
These were a big hit on my Christmas cookie tray. They froze well. Thank you for a terrific recipe!
I’m so sorry for just now seeing your comment! I didn’t realize I wouldn’t have internet at my in-laws over the holidays. :/ I’m happy to hear that you enjoyed the cookies! Thanks for your comment and sorry again.
These are insanely delicious! My poor GF dad is used to having crummy tasting food and desserts. This is the best GF cookie we’ve ever had. You’ve given us good food again. Thank you a million times!
I’m so terribly sorry for just now seeing your comment! I didn’t realize I wouldn’t have internet at my in-laws over the holidays. :( I’m happy to hear that you and your dad enjoyed these. And your poor dad! I have tons of gluten-free desserts and I promise they’re all far from crumbly. Thanks for your comment and sorry again for being so slow to reply!
I made these vegan- subbed in aquafaba (chickpea juice) and a bit of ground flax- turned out delicious! they were a little delicate…but very good. i feel like these are a can’t miss!
I love that you made them vegan! How much aquafaba did you use? Thanks for the tip! I’m so happy that they came out well with your subs. :)
idk how i never saw this! 3T is what iused. That is the standard measure of aquafaba used to = 1 whole egg
Awesome! Thanks so much for letting me know. :)
Can I use almond meal instead of blanched almond flour?
😊
Yes, if you don’t mind the little bits of almond skin! :)
Can you use gluten free baking flour as a sub for the coconut flour? If so, use the same amount? And if using butter as a sub for coconut oil, should you use the same amount?
Hoping to bake these tonight!
Unfortunately not. There’s no sub for the coconut flour as it absorbs so much more liquid than any other type of flour. I’ve heard that oat flour sometimes works in some recipes but I have no idea if it’d work here. Use 8 tablespoons of butter in place of the 7 1/2 tbsp of coconut oil. I’d love to hear how they come out!
Can the coconut flour be left out and just up the almond flour?
Unfortunately not. :( I’ve tried. They don’t come out with the right texture.
I am bewildered about the 4 days life of these cookies. Does this mean they must b e eaten as soon as baked? My usual Christmas cookies are kept in tins for several weeks. HELP how can they keep longer?
Of course they last longer (I’m sure a few weeks would be fine) but they won’t be as tasty as fresh or if you eat them within 4 days. There’s nothing to add to them that’ll make them last longer. You could freeze them if you like!
These were so good. I did have a problem with then falling apart when I was rolling and thumbprinting them. I added a tiny bit more coconut oil but in retrospect maybe I should have added another egg or the egg white of another egg. It just seemed to crumbly. I also baked about a minute longer. So good though! Thanks for the recipe. 🤗
I’m happy you enjoyed them! It seems like some people find them crumbly but I never have. I guess it depends on the type of almond flour you use. Thanks for your comment. :)
Just made these with butter. Rolled in whipped egg whites and almond flour before baking. Delicious. A great hit. Will make these again.
The egg whites is a great idea! Thanks for the tip and your comment. :)
I just made these and they are very good! I did sub butter for the coconut oil though. Thanks for the easy recipe.
You’re welcome! I’m happy to hear that you liked them. :) Thanks for your comment!
Love…. Love…. Love these cookies! They are a part of our traditional annual baking day! Lol, we usually just dip pretzels in almond bark (a long time joke), but it’s official! We actually bake now!
These look delicious! Do they freeze well?
Thanks! They do. :)
Can I substitute almond flour with another flour? If yes, what would you recommend?
Thank you 😊
Hi there! I’m sorry for just now seeing your question. Almond flour is really only interchangeable with other types of nut flours / meals. I haven’t tried anything other than almond flour in this recipe, but I think cashew meal could work.
I absolutely Love the variety of gluten free recipes you have. However, I am searching DESPERATELY for cookies; especially Christmas and other major holiday options for my granddaughter who is 4 years old and is allergic to tree nuts, coconut, sesame seeds, and beans. How in the world am I going to find a variety of options so this little one will not be left out when doing my annual baking for eight grandchildren? Can you help PLEASE ???
Hi there! I’m so very sorry for just now seeing your comment. It landed in spam for some weird reason! Most of my recipes unfortunately use almond flour or coconut flour / oil / sugar (because of my intolerances). Can she have Bob’s Red Mill Gluten-Free 1-to-1 Baking Flour? If so, I might have a few recipes I could recommend! And this molasses cookies recipe works, I think!
I can’t eat coconut due to allergy. Do you have suggestions for coconut flour?
Thanks
There’s unfortunately no sub for coconut flour as it absorbs so much more liquid than any other flour. Sorry about that! Some people have mentioned oat flour but I’ve never tried it.
I’ve seen a recipe which uses oat flour and a little tapioca starch. Just search pinterest for gluten free thumbprint cookies almond and oat flour and it will come up.
We love these. I did try them with butter and KA measure for measure flour and they did not work. When we followed the recipe 😊 they worked fine. I don’t try to too then but use a small cookie scoop. I like the rustic look so we don’t re-roll them. I use a 1/4 tsp to make the indentation. The original recipe yeilded about 18 cookies.
Haha. Well I’m happy you decided to make them again, following the recipe. :) 1-to-1 GF baking flours are usually meant for subbing for wheat flour, so it makes sense that it wouldn’t work here (though I guess it’s always worth trying :)) Thanks so much for your feedback!
These are absolutely delicious. I substituted Lakanto classic monkfruit for the sugar. I had the same issue as Shannon with the cookies breaking apart when I pressed my thumbprint in. It was pretty time consuming to form them. However, I think I may know why this happened- when the recipe calls for 7 T of coconut oil, does that mean measure 7 solid T of coconut oil and melt it, or does it mean 7 T of melted coconut oil? I did the latter, and I’m thinking you meant the former.
Hi Krista! I’m happy that you enjoyed them. :) It’s great to know that Lakanto works well! I actually have some and never use it. Thanks a bunch for the tip. 1 tablespoon of coconut oil is 14 grams, whether it’s measured solid or melted. So it doesn’t matter if you measure before or after it’s melted. I really think it might just be the almond flour. Thanks for your comment!
Do I blanch the almond flour or can I buy it blanched? If I do it…how? I’m new to gluten free baking.
Hi there! Most almond flour is already blanched and if it’s not, it’s usually called almond meal. It’s not something you have to do yourself! :)
Everyone loves these. I’ve made them so many times and they are always a hit. The finished product has always been perfect. I find these to be *much* more time consuming than the recipe suggests. i.e. I do not have the choice whether or not to reshape the edges to “make them prettier”. Prettiness is not the issue. If I just push my thumb in the center they split from the middle into about 5 or ten pieces, kind of like pie slices. I don’t reshape the edges because I want to make them prettier. If you want an actual well that can be filled with jam, you *need” to reshape the edges to make the cookies functional (hold jam). I’ve been making this recipe for over 2 years and I make it often. It’s probably my favourite recipe. it takes me at least an hour just to form these cookies into a good enough shape though. They don’t hold together like normal cookie dough (and I wouldn’t expect them to) but they taste so good. Chilling the dough before forming the cookies does help though! If time is an issue though, I would never be able to make these in 30 minutes. Normally about 75-90 minutes. The bake time is right for me. It really is just the best recipe.
I’m happy that you’ve been enjoying them! :) I’ve also made them a whole lot but have never needed close to an hour to shape them. What brand of almond flour are you using? I would suggest trying a different one and seeing if that helps. Brands vary so much in how finely they’re ground, which has an impact on how dry (and therefore less easy to form) the dough is.
Thanks for the tips! I’ve used all different brands and not noticed much difference. If you think it might be that my dough is a little dry though, I might try adding a little bit of an extra egg and see if that helps. I use coconut flour in baking fairly often so I know it holds moisture if it’s mixed with egg. I’m sure I’ll keep experimenting probably for ever so I’ll keep you posted ;)
Haha. Experimenting forever. ;) I think your egg idea is a good one. I hope it goes well! You also try decreasing the coconut flour a little bit.
Can you use stevia as a sweetener?
I’m really not sure as I’ve never used it. Sorry about that!
I can’t do sugar. Do you think honey could be used?
The problem is that there’s no liquid to reduce in the recipe, which is necessary because of the liquid you’re adding from the honey. So I can’t really recommend it. Sorry about that!
So delicious!! I wonder how they would get if I add whey protein to them? And how much
So happy you like them! :) I’ve never added protein to my cookies so I have no idea. Sorry about that!
These cookies changed my whole bias against gluten- and dairy-free baking – soooo delicious!! I have no personal dietary restrictions but made these for guests – but would definitely make them again for myself & family.
Awesome! So happy to hear that you’ll make them again for yourself. :) Thanks for your comment!
They taste delicious! I did use coconut sugar instead and they got nice brownish colour! Such a an easy, tasty tea snack . Thank you!!!!!
You’re welcome! Good to know that coconut sugar works well. :) Thanks for your comment!
Great easy recipe. Soft and chewy biscuits.
So happy you liked them!
How well do you think these would freeze?
I’m so very sorry for just now seeing your comment! I don’t know where the week went. Do you mean the baked cookies? I haven’t tried it myself but I think it’d work fine.
Got the recipe from nephew Darryl, very easy and very tasty!
So happy he shared the recipe with you and that you enjoyed it! Thanks for your comment. :)
Can I use only coconut flour as almond flour is not easy to find where I live or maybe regular flour ? TA
Coconut flour isn’t interchangeable with any other flours as it absorbs so much more liquid. :( Sorry about that!
I didn’t have the coconut flour so I substituted it with the same amount of all-purpose gluten free flour and it did worked fine and they taste great.
Good to know that works! Thanks for the tip. :)
Can you use butter instead of coconut oil. If so how much butter.
1/2 cup. :)
Can i use coconut sugar instead of white sugar?
Would these cookies freeze well & should i freeze them without the jam?
I haven’t tried it (coconut sugar or freezing) but I think it’d work. You would probably be able to freeze them with the jam just fine.
Hi Erin! These are amazing! I made some yesterday however some of them fell apart. I didn’t substitute any ingredients. Just wondering how I could keep them from falling apart? Add more almond or coconut flour? Anyway, I would still eat them if they are broken. Will try coconut sugar next time. Thank you!
Hi there! You could try adding some kind of binder (like an egg) but since I haven’t tried it, I have no idea if it’d work. Adding more flour would just add to the problem! Some of the reviewers have had them fall apart but it seems like most people haven’t. I’m not sure what the issue could be if you’re following the recipe! What brand of almond flour did you use? I’m so happy you liked them, though. :)
Thanks for a great recipe! I made these for my work Christmas party, so myself and a coworker could have a safe, gluten-free treat!
You’re welcome! I’m happy to hear that they came out well. :) Thanks for your comment!
Made them today for hubby’s birthday (filled with butter cream frosting at his request) and they turned out so perfect! I used the weight measurements and my egg probably wasn’t as room temp as it should be and my almond flour was about 15 minutes out of the freezer, so it may have chilled the melted coconut oil a little, but the dough was still perfectly soft for rolling and baking.
Can’t wait to try it with xylitol (using an all fruit raspberry jam) for a low carb option! Thank you!!
I’m happy that they came out well! I’d love to hear how the low-carb version comes out. :) Thanks a bunch for your comment and I hope your husband had a great birthday!
Thank you! I can’t wait to make these!
You’re welcome! I hope you’ll enjoy them! :)
For everyone having “issues” with baking gluten free, I have learned a valuable lesson. When working with almond flour you will discover brand to brand huge differences, even though they look similar or identical what is produced in the end varies. I use one brand for bread like texture and another for another application.
So true! I wrote a whole post about it here (that’s my paleo chocolate chip cookie recipe). Thanks for your comment!
I made these cookies today. I substituted a Flax egg. They came out perfect! I used apricot and raspberry preserves. Delicious!
It’s great to know that a flax egg works well! Thanks for the tip. :) I’m so happy you liked the cookies!
These are amazing! Thank you so much! I had a hankering for a Fall cookie so I just whipped up a modified batch. I just added a little cinnamon to the cookie dough and used home-made apple butter instead of the raspberry jam! I am warming my caramel sauce to drizzle right now! These won’t last long! Thank you!
Oh, yum! That sounds incredible. I’ll have to try your version! Thanks for sharing. :)
Hello,
My cookies were a bit crumbly not “wet” batter. I squeezed it together to bring it together and let it sit for 10-15 mins. Wonder why..? Thank you!
Hello! Did you make any subs or any kind of changes at all to the recipe? If not, I’m not sure what the issue could be. I make these so often and have never had them come out crumbly! I hope they still came out tasty. :)
They came out wonderful, my clients I cook for, couldn’t stop eating them. Whatever happened, not sure. But that were great and eaten fast😊 Thank you!
Awesome! So happy to hear that. Thanks for your comment! :)
Yes, mine crumbled as well, but I managed to press them into balls. I did not make any substitutions, except strawberry preserve instead of raspberry. making for a fund raiser, so not going to be able to taste them, besides I eat paleo, so the sugar doesn’t work for me. Hopefully they will be a good seller! They smell delicious & look great!
I’m happy that they came out well! I hope that they were a hit at the fundraiser. :)
I only got 12 cookies out of this recipe so hope they are not too big! I set the timer for 10 min instead of 8. They are a bit doughy. Thank you! #glutenfreelady
I hope you enjoyed them! Thanks for your feedback. :)
These are so good. Here’s how I made them from your recipe…I only had one cup of almond flour so I used 1 cup of oat flour with the almond flour. I added the coconut flour and a couple teaspoons of a nut milk. I only had unrefined coconut oil so I used a refined walnut oil I had. I used a seedless black raspberry jam and they turned out perfect for me. Your recipe will be made many more times in the future. Thank you for sharing it with us Erin.
That’s awesome that the almond flour and oat flour sub worked! That’s great to know. And black raspberry jam sounds delicious! I’ll have to try that. Thanks for your comment and so sorry for just now seeing it! I’m in the process of moving and things are chaotic.
Can honey be substituted for the sugar?!
You could try but it would totally change the texture of the cookies and make them cakey and probably too flat. I don’t recommend it!
Hi! I’d really like to try and make these but I have no coconut flour! Could I use corn flour instead??
Hello! Coconut flour is unfortunately not interchangeable with any other flour as it absorbs so much more liquid. Sorry about that!
Thank you for the speedy reply!! OK I will wait till I go shopping to make them! Also thank you for listing the ingredients in metric measurements! For European’s it’s a real time saver! No need to convert them :)
Thank you for the speedy reply!! OK I will wait till I go shopping to make them! Also thank you for listing the ingredients in metric measurements! For European’s it’s a real time saver! No need to convert them :) :)
You’re welcome! I hate using cups, especially for grain-free baking. ;)
Hi there,
I am so excited to try these… They look delicious!
I was wondering, can I substitute a natural sweetener such as Erythritol instead of using actual cane sugar?
Thank you!
Hello! I’ve always had bad luck when trying to use low-carb sweeteners like erythritol. So I really have no idea if that’d work here. I’m sorry I don’t have a better answer for you!
I subbed the cane sugar for 1/4 cup xylitol and 1/4 cup swerve and they turned out perfect….so yummy!!!!
Good to know! Thanks a bunch for your tip. I’m happy to hear that they came out well. :)
Just made these cookies and they turned out great! I used 7 tbl butter because I was out of coconut oil and used Smuckers simply fruit jelly for the centers after I baked them. Thanks for the recipe!
So happy you liked them! Good to know that you can add the jelly after baking. Thanks for your comment. :)
Delicious! Made half with almond extract with raspberry jam and the other half with lemon extract and homemade paleo lemon curd.
Yum! I’ve made these with lemon curd, too and they’re so, so good. :) I’m happy you liked them, too. Thanks for your comment!
Hi there! The recipe’s correct (hence all the great reviews :)) Someone tags me on Instagram every few days with their pictures of these cookies (you can see some examples here, here, here, and here) and nobody seems to have issues with them – except for one of the commenters below you, who had the same issue.
She then made them again with a different type of flour and said that they were very tasty. What brand of almond flour did you use? And did you make any changes or subs at all to the recipe? I’m guessing either one of the ingredients or one of the measurements were off. Or perhaps you really, really packed the almond flour? But even then, I don’t think it’d come out crumbly and dry. There have been times when I follow one of my own recipes (which has nothing but great reviews) and they come out terribly. Then I realize I added too much or too little of something. It happens. :/ I’m sorry! I hope you’ll give them another try. :) Maybe you could use a scale next time, if you didn’t last time.
Hello! Someone tags me on Instagram every few days with their pictures of these cookies (you can see some examples here, here, here, and here) and nobody seems to have issues with them – except for one of the commenters below you, who had the same issue.
She then made them again with a different type of flour and said that they were very tasty. What brand of almond flour did you use? And did you make any changes or subs at all to the recipe? I’m guessing either one of the ingredients or one of the measurements were off. Or perhaps you really, really packed the almond flour? But even then, I don’t think it’d come out crumbly and dry. There have been times when I follow one of my own recipes (which has nothing but great reviews) and they come out terribly. Then I realize I added too much or too little of something. It happens. :/ I’m sorry! I hope you’ll give them another try. :) Maybe you could use a scale next time, if you didn’t last time.
Thanks, Erin for shairng this recipe. These cookies are easy and excellent.
I lived Germany years ago and these taste a lot like spitzbuben, a german almond cookie, filled with raspberry jam.
I’m happy you enjoyed them! I live in Germany and have never tried Spitzbuben. I’ll have to try those out. Thanks for the tip and for your feedback!
Im not a big fan of almond extract- have you ever substituted with vanilla extract?
Thank you!
You can use whatever extract you’d like. :) I like lemon but vanilla works, too!
I have the THM baking blend and I was wondering if I could use that? It has organic coconut flour, golden flax meal, almond flour and oat fiber.
Unfortunately not. This recipe uses a mix of almond flour + coconut flour and there’s not really a sub for either of those (though you could use another type of nut flour instead of almond flour). Sorry about that! Does it say on the bag how it’s supposed to be used? Like a sub for AP flour or something like that?
The suggested uses are: muffins and biscuits, pancakes and waffles and bread. Thanks for the quick reply!
These look great! Do they freeze well?
Thanks! And they do. Hope you’ll enjoy them! :)
Is there a substitute for coconut flour?
Unfortunately, coconut flour’s not interchangeable with any other type of flour as it absorbs so much more liquid. Sorry about that!
These look so yummy! Can you substitute butter for the coconut oil?
You can use 1/2 cup butter in place of the coconut oil. Enjoy! :)
What brand of almond flour do you use? I know that almond flours vary and want to make sure I use one that works with the recipe.
Thanks!
I’ve used Bob’s Red Mill and several different random brands of German almond flour without issue. :) Enjoy!
I am hoping to make these for a cookie exchange this year. Have you ever tried using an egg replacer? I have an egg allergy.
I’m sorry but I haven’t tried that. If I were you, I’d try a chia egg. Good luck if you try it out! :)
I’m gluten free but not dairy free. Can I use butter in place of coconut oil?
You can use 1/2 cup butter in place of the coconut oil. Enjoy! :)
This looks amazing but when I tried it it was very dry… I added another egg and t more tablespoons of oil but it still wouldn’t form into a ball between my hands. What could I be doing wrong?
Hi there! I’m sorry you’re having difficulties! What brand of almond flour did you use? And did you make any changes or subs at all to the recipe? None of the other commenters have had that issue (and I’ve made these tons of times) so either one of the ingredients or one of the measurements were off. Or perhaps you really, really packed the almond flour? But even then, I don’t think it’d come out crumbly and dry. There have been times when I follow one of my own recipes (which has nothing but great reviews) and they come out terribly. Then I realize I added too much or too little of something. It happens. :/ I’m sorry! I hope you’ll give them another try. :) Maybe you could use a scale next time, if you didn’t last time.
Thanks for your quick reply. I measured very carefully (using the scale) so I
am not sure where I went wrong. I think it might be my flour. Thanks anyway, I will try again with new flour!
Good luck with the next batch! :)
New flour, no problem! Very tasty cookies, thank you!
Yay! I’m happy you enjoyed them. :) What kind of flour did you use that didn’t work? I’m asking so the other commenters can avoid it. :)
Soft and chewy as promised! Thank you so much for sharing this recipe! I recently developed a gluten intolerance and was seriously freaking out about all the holiday baking I was going to miss. These turned out so good!
I’m thrilled you found the recipe and that you enjoyed them! I’m not actually GF but I have loads of GF recipes that are super tasty so I hope you’ll try some others, too. :) Thanks for your comment!
Hi Erin would I be able to use ground almond instead of almond flour, I have that in my pantry and all the other ingredients just don’t really want to have to go to the supermarket until I need to go shopping again, thanks
Hi there! I see that you have a UK email address. I believe that almond flour = ground almonds in the UK so you have what you need. :) I hope you’ll enjoy the cookies!
I LOVE raspberry thumbprint cookies, and I’d like to make these for my daughter, but I can’t have almond. Is there another flour I could substitute and still get the same beautiful, delicious results?
You could use another type of nut flour or nut meal but then the cookies would taste like nuts (these don’t taste nutty unless you add extract). Hazelnut meal and raspberry jam sounds tasty, though! Maybe cashew meal would also be nice.
Hello!
These look amazing! Can’t wait to try.
Would these work to cut the recipe in half? I don’t have enough people to consume 32 cookies ;)
Hi there! And yes, you can halve the recipe. :) For half an egg, whisk one egg and use 25 grams. Or you could just freeze the dough and make the other half later!
Can you substitute all coconut flour for the almond flour? Or would it come out to dry?
Unfortunately not. The two flours aren’t interchangeable (coconut flour isn’t interchangeable with any kind of flour) and almond flour could only be swapped out for another type of nut flour. Sorry about that!
I made these cookies the other day,my first time using coconut and almond flour and wow they are so good.I bought lots of bob’s red mill products on my trip and started baking the day I got home(first time touching a bob’s red mill flour and coconut sugar..so exciting!) and can’t wait to try more recipes.I used coconut sugar because I wanna put that sugar in everything!I’m just a little bit too excited!:)
thanks for your amazing recipes
Oh, yay! I’m so excited for you! I’m very happy that you were able to get some Bob’s Red Mill on your trip to Dubai. :) I haven’t tried these with coconut sugar because I thought it’d lessen the almond or lemon taste. Did it work well? Thanks a bunch for your comment! I hope you’ll enjoy the other recipes just as much. :)
Thank you:)
I’m not sure how almondy! these cookies are supposed to taste but I think it did lessen almond flavour a little bit,anyway I loved it.
Well if you loved it, then it’s all good. I’ll have to try coconut sugar next time! Thanks again for your comment. :)
Yummy,
made your gluten free version, made them small cause they are so good.
Your recipes are right I do have to leave them in a bit longer 15min but are wonderful
I’m so happy you enjoyed them and the other recipes! Thanks for your feedback. :)
Erin, I agree. Why are thumbprint cookies only baked and shared during the holidays? Raspberry thumbprints are my favorites and I cannot wait to try this grain-free version. Your Grain-free Lemon Curd Thumbprint Cookies ROCK! In fact, I pinned them to BHG’s World’s Largest Cookie Exchange last month. :) Thanks for sharing, girl. I hope your holidays were fabulous! xo
I hope you enjoyed the holidays, too! And thanks so much for pinning my cookies. :)
Hey there,
Really delicious article! ;) I really love your photos. Is it iPhone only or are you using a specific camera?
Cheers!
Matt
What a great cookie to bring to a cookie exchange!
Definitely! Now if someone would just invite me to one. ;)
Lovely cookies! they look like cute blossoms!
Thanks! And aww, they do! I hadn’t noticed that.
Look so good, any recommendations on replacing the egg ?
Thanks! And unfortunately not. I know a lot of people have success with flax eggs but I’ve never tried that sub myself. Sorry about that!
I want to dive face-first into that raspberry center! YUM!
Sounds like a good plan! ;)
Love these, I can never say no to a thumbprint cookie!
And they’re grain-free, for your pleasure! ;)
Those look 12-months-a-year good!
I totally agree! :)
Thumbprint cookies make me happy, and these with their chewy raspberry centers look perfect.
Same here! They remind me of my childhood.
I could several of these right now. They look so very yummy.
I’d love some right about now, too! :)
Super cute cookies! I’m intrigued by the dairy free white chocolate. I’ll definately be giving that a go for Christmas
Let me know how it goes! I’ve never actually tried it myself.
Such gorgeous cookies for the holidays!
Thanks so much!
I love that you never let us down. A fantastic cookie that can be gifted to those friends and family with allergies and intolerances. Almond and raspberry are one if my favourite flavour pairings. Fab recipe. Sammie.
Aww, thanks! What a nice comment. :) And I’m with you – raspberry and almond are perfect together! Thanks again for your lovely comment. :)
Raspberry is my absolute favorite flavor to put into a thumbprint cookie! There’s just something about it that takes me back to being a little kid :)
Me, too! They just seem so comforting. :)
I bet the almond flour makes these incredible with the raspberry. YUM!
It does indeed! Especially with the almond extract. :)
Thank you so much for this recipe! I made these today and they are delicious. The only thing I did different was roll the cookie dough in finely chopped pecans and use strawberry jam instead of raspberry. I made them for a school event, but can’t wait to make them again for my family. Merry Christmas!
I love your idea of rolling them in chopped pecans! I’m definitely going to try that. I’m happy that you liked them and will be making them again! Thanks for your comment. :)